Skip to main content

Joel Greenblatt

Joel Greenblatt is a renowned investor, hedge fund manager, and author, known for developing the "Magic Formula" for investing in undervalued, high-performing stocks. As the founder of Gotham Capital, he achieved exceptional returns through value investing and quantitative analysis strategies.

In this document, we will explore his career, the methodology behind the Magic Formula, his investment strategies, and the impact of his teachings on the financial world.

1.    Biography and Career of Joel Greenblatt

1.1  Early Life and Education

Joel Greenblatt was born in 1957 and studied at Wharton University, where he earned an MBA in Finance. In 1985, he founded Gotham Capital, a hedge fund that achieved an annualized return of over 40% in its early years.

1.2  Investment Philosophy

Greenblatt is a strong advocate of value investing, drawing inspiration from figures like Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett. His goal is to find undervalued companies with high returns on invested capital.

1.3  Notable Publications

He is the author of influential books such as:

  • You Can Be a Stock Market Genius (1997): Explains advanced investment strategies.
  • The Little Book That Beats the Market (2005): Introduces the Magic Formula for selecting profitable stocks.

2.    The Magic Formula for Investing

2.1  What is the Magic Formula?

Greenblatt designed a quantitative method for selecting stocks based on two fundamental metrics:

  1. Return on Capital (ROC): Measures how efficiently a company generates profits with its capital.
  2. Earnings Yield: The ratio of earnings to stock price, similar to the inverse of the P/E ratio.

* https://www.magicformulainvesting.com/

2.2  Stock Selection Process

The Magic Formula follows these steps:

  1. Calculate the ROC and Earnings Yield for all stocks in the market.
  2. Rank each company based on these metrics.
  3. Combine both rankings and select the companies with the highest scores.
  4. Build a diversified portfolio of the top 20-30 stocks.
  5. Hold each investment for one year, then rebalance the portfolio.

2.3  Advantages and Limitations

Advantages:

  • Easy-to-apply strategy without requiring qualitative analysis.
  • Based on proven value investing principles.
  • Has historically outperformed the market in the long term.

Limitations:

  • Can result in high short-term volatility.
  • Some companies may be undervalued due to structural issues.
  • Does not account for qualitative factors such as a company's competitive advantage.

3.    Applying the Strategy in the Market

3.1  Historical Performance

Studies conducted by Greenblatt have shown that over periods of more than 10 years, the Magic Formula has consistently outperformed the market, with an annualized return exceeding 20%.

3.2  Adaptation for Different Types of Investors

  • Individual Investors: Can apply the strategy by manually selecting stocks.
  • Fund Managers: Can use the methodology as a complement to other quantitative models.

3.3  Success Stories

Gotham Capital has successfully used Greenblatt's methodology, generating above-average market returns for several decades.

4.    Relationship Between Joel Greenblatt and Michael Burry

Joel Greenblatt and Michael Burry share a notable connection in the investment world. Burry, founder of Scion Capital and known for his bet against the housing market before the 2008 crisis, has cited Greenblatt as one of his key influences in value investing.

4.1  Gotham Capital’s Support for Burry

When Michael Burry launched his hedge fund, Scion Capital, in 2000, he attracted the attention of Joel Greenblatt. Gotham Capital was one of the first institutional investors to support Burry, trusting his ability to find undervalued opportunities in the market. This backing allowed Burry to manage capital from prominent investors and establish his reputation on Wall Street.

4.2  Shared Investment Philosophies

Although each developed their own distinct approach, both share fundamental principles:

  • Value investing: Identifying undervalued companies through meticulous financial data analysis.
  • Quantitative analysis: While Burry leans more toward fundamental research, both rely on metrics to evaluate investment opportunities.
  • Investment discipline: Applying a methodical, rule-based approach, avoiding impulsive or emotional decisions.

4.3  Differences in Their Approach

  • Greenblatt: His Magic Formula approach ranks companies based on return on capital and earnings yield.
  • Burry: Prefers deeper balance sheet analysis and macroeconomic trends, such as his detection of the subprime mortgage bubble.

The connection between them demonstrates how a mentor and an emerging investor can share strategies while applying them uniquely to achieve success in financial markets.

5.    Key Investment Lessons from Joel Greenblatt

  1. Follow a structured method: Discipline is crucial to avoid emotional mistakes.
  2. Don’t worry about volatility: In the long term, fair valuations prevail.
  3. Diversify wisely: A portfolio of 20-30 well-selected stocks reduces risk.
  4. Invest for the long term: Patience is key to leveraging compound growth.
  5. Trust the numbers: A data-driven approach tends to outperform intuition and emotion.
Back to top